Advertisement

SKIP ADVERTISEMENT
You have a preview view of this article while we are checking your access. When we have confirmed access, the full article content will load.

Michelle Goldberg

Some Leftists Are Boycotting This Film. Everyone Should Watch It.

An illustration including a blue-tinted image of Nadav Lapid.
Credit...Illustration by The New York Times
Listen · 5:57 min

In 2021, the Israeli film director Nadav Lapid moved to France because, he told me, he felt his country was in a state of “total moral collapse.” After Oct. 7, as Israel ground much of Gaza into dust, Lapid returned to Israel to make “Yes,” an impossibly scathing, bitterly surreal attempt to capture that collapse on film.

“Yes” tells the story of a struggling pianist and party entertainer known only as Y who is commissioned to write a new national anthem celebrating genocide in Gaza. (The song borrows from a real one in a video by an Israeli nationalist group.) Lapid’s film is a vision of a traumatized country where life has become a frenzy of orgiastic partying and histrionic self-righteousness. It’s like “The Zone of Interest,” the 2023 film about the banal life of a Nazi family living next to Auschwitz, with Eurovision aesthetics. Though of course, as Lapid has pointed out, “The Zone of Interest” wasn’t made while the Holocaust was happening. In “Yes,” you can sometimes see and hear the real-world annihilation of Gaza in the distance.

Making “Yes” in a country at war and bursting with national fervor wasn’t easy. Many in the Israeli film industry refused to have anything to do with it; Lapid had to bring a makeup artist in from Serbia. He’d received money from the Israel Film Fund, which gets Israeli taxpayer funding but works independently of the government, and he feared that if the Ministry of Culture found out what he was up to it would find a way to shut the production down. So he forbade his actors from posting anything about the project online. He dodged the military to film guerrilla-style along the Gaza border.

“Yes” has been furiously denounced by leaders in Israel. The night of the Ophir awards — Israel’s version of the Oscars — police officers detained its star, the left-wing performance artist Ariel Bronz, on dubious grounds. (They said they were investigating whether a poem he’d posted on Facebook months earlier incited terrorism.)

Israeli outrage about the film was predictable. More surprising is that some leftists in Europe are boycotting Lapid and his work in the name of Palestinian solidarity. Last month, about a dozen pro-Palestinian filmmakers threatened to pull out of the Marseille International Film Festival because Lapid, an Israeli who’d taken public money, was going to be on the jury. Not wanting to cause trouble for the organizers, Lapid agreed to step down and instead hold a public master class on his films, but that too was canceled under pressure. “For them, even if I would have been selling hot dogs in the festival, it wouldn’t be legitimate,” he told me.

This wasn’t the first time that Lapid has felt stung by the European left. In Spain, he said, the movie screened under police protection because of bomb threats. An Italian distributor turned it down, he said, because she didn’t want to be accused of releasing movies from a genocidal state. And though “Yes” premiered at Cannes, the most prestigious film festival in the world, he thinks others have shied away from him and his work because they feared precisely the sort of dispute that broke out in Marseille.


Thank you for your patience while we verify access. If you are in Reader mode please exit and log into your Times account, or subscribe for all of The Times.


Thank you for your patience while we verify access.

Already a subscriber? Log in.

Want all of The Times? Subscribe.

Related Content

Advertisement

SKIP ADVERTISEMENT